Debate: Let Them Come - We Have Nothing to Fear From High Levels of Immigration
Debates • 1h 48m
When the EU's transitional immigration rules expire on 1st January 2014, numerous Bulgarians and Romanians will be heading for Britain. And we should put out the welcome mat. Yes, it's true that there has been a huge fuss about this in the press, but then xenophobia sells newspapers. The truth is that like the other waves of immigrants to Britain, those coming here will overwhelmingly be people with initiative, people who want to better their prospects. And our economy needs them. Immigrants don't steal jobs from the existing British workforce: all the evidence suggests they make possible the creation of new jobs. Mass immigration has always enriched economies and cultures and never more so than in the present globalised world. Yes, it's easy to stoke the fires of xenophobia and get the British public all ugly on the issue, but it's wrong: the pundits and the politicians should be allaying public fears of immigration not pandering to them.
That's the liberal "metropolitan" line, but as its critics see it, it overlooks a crucial aspect of the human personality: we are not a random jumble of individuals who just happen to inhabit the same small island. We are a nation, they say: and our sense of identity with nation is, or should be, central to who we are. And while no civilised nation, least of all Britain, should be opposed to immigration, we should be opposed to the unprecedented scale on which it has been occurring. It's the numbers, stupid. Immigrants have undoubtedly enriched our culture, but for there to be such a thing as British culture, for there to be a sense of nationhood and national pride, it is essential that the newcomers be absorbed into British life rather than form distinct cultural colonies. There's nothing racist about this. Nothing racist in feeling apprehensive about the next influx from Eastern Europe, for example. It's not just a matter of what that might mean for our overstrained services and for British citizens competing for low-paid jobs: it's the damage done to our sense of belonging to the same community. This isn't some kind of extremist position: as polls have shown, seven out of ten Britons think there are too many foreigners in the country.
Up Next in Debates
Debate: The West Should Pay Reparatio...
They are the crimes for which no one has ever made amends. The transatlantic slave trade enslaved between 10 and 12 million Africans. Historians estimate that 15 to 25% of the men and women packed into the slave ships died before they reached the Americas. The only people ever to be compensated? ...
Debate: There is Nothing Wrong With R...
Fancy a nice juicy steak? Most of us do from time to time, and we don’t trouble our consciences too much with the rights and wrongs of eating meat. Others, while vaguely aware that we ought to go vegan, just can’t face the rest of our lives denying ourselves bacon, beef, butter etc. But once we s...
Too Many People go to University
Filmed at the Royal Geographical Society on 30th January 2007.
Speakers for the motion: Claire Fox, Anatole Kaletsky, Jenna Nicholas
Speakers against the motion: Baroness Onora O'Neill, Mary Ann Sieghart
Chair: Sir Clement Freud